What happens if 1031 exchange fails?

Question

What are the potential consequences and tax implications if a 1031 exchange does not meet the necessary requirements for deferral, and how can a taxpayer address or mitigate these issues to ensure compliance with IRS regulations?

ARTE's Answer

When a 1031 exchange fails, it means that the transaction does not meet the requirements set forth by the IRS for a tax-deferred exchange. This can result in the recognition of capital gains, which would be taxable in the year the relinquished property was sold. There are several reasons why a 1031 exchange might fail, and understanding these can help you avoid pitfalls.

  1. Failure to Identify Replacement Property: One of the most common reasons for a failed exchange is not identifying a replacement property within the 45-day identification period. According to Section 1.1031(k)-1(b) of the Income Tax Regulations, the taxpayer must identify the replacement property within 45 days of transferring the relinquished property. If this deadline is missed, the exchange fails.
  2. Failure to Acquire Replacement Property: Even if a replacement property is identified, the taxpayer must acquire it within 180 days of the transfer of the relinquished property or by the due date of the taxpayer's tax return for that year, whichever is earlier. If the replacement property is not acquired within this timeframe, the exchange fails.
  3. Constructive Receipt of Funds: If the taxpayer receives or has control over the proceeds from the sale of the relinquished property, it can result in constructive receipt, which disqualifies the exchange. This is why using a qualified intermediary, like us at Deferred.com, is crucial. We ensure that the taxpayer does not have access to the funds, maintaining the integrity of the exchange.
  4. Qualified Intermediary Default: If the qualified intermediary defaults, such as through bankruptcy, and cannot acquire the replacement property, the exchange may fail. However, Revenue Procedure 2010-14 provides a safe harbor for taxpayers in this situation, allowing them to report the gain over time using the installment method if certain conditions are met.

Example Scenario: Let's say you own an investment property with a fair market value of $500,000 and an adjusted basis of $300,000. You decide to sell this property and engage in a 1031 exchange to defer the $200,000 gain. You choose Deferred.com as your qualified intermediary to facilitate the exchange.

You sell your property and Deferred.com holds the $500,000 proceeds. You identify a replacement property worth $550,000 within the 45-day period. However, due to unforeseen circumstances, you are unable to close on the replacement property within the 180-day period. As a result, the exchange fails.

In this case, the $200,000 gain becomes taxable in the year of the sale. If Deferred.com had defaulted due to bankruptcy, you might have been able to use the safe harbor provisions of Revenue Procedure 2010-14 to report the gain over time, provided you met the necessary requirements.

To avoid a failed exchange, it's essential to plan carefully, adhere to the strict timelines, and work with a reliable qualified intermediary like us at Deferred.com. We help ensure that the exchange process is smooth and compliant with IRS regulations, minimizing the risk of a failed exchange.

Have more questions? Call us at 866-442-1031 or send an email to support@deferred.com to talk with an exchange officer at Deferred.

Deferred's AI Real Estate Tax Expert (ARTE) is a free research tool. Trained on 8,000+ pages of US tax law, regulations and rulings, ARTE outperforms human test takers on the CPA exam. This is page has ARTE's response to a common 1031 Exchange question and should not be considered personalized tax advice.

Sources

1031 Question? Ask ARTE

Deferred's AI 1031 Research Assistant is trained on 8,000+ pages of US tax law and outperforms human CPAs by 22%+

CHAT NOW

Learn More

See more frequently asked questions about 1031 exchanges

How does a 721 exchange differ from a 1031 exchange?
What are the key differences between a Section 721 exchange and a Section 1031 exchange, particularly in terms of their application, benefits, and requirements for deferring taxes on real estate transactions?
How long do i have for a 1031 exchange?
What is the timeframe for completing a 1031 exchange, including the deadlines for identifying and acquiring replacement property, to ensure compliance with IRS regulations and successfully defer capital gains taxes?
How much do you have to reinvest in 1031 exchange?
What is the minimum amount I need to reinvest in a 1031 exchange to fully defer capital gains taxes, and how does this relate to the sale price and proceeds from my relinquished property?
Can you do a 1031 exchange out of the country?
Is it possible to conduct a 1031 exchange involving real property located outside the United States, and if so, what are the specific conditions or limitations that apply to such international exchanges under the current tax code?
Do i need a qualified intermediary for a 1031 exchange?
Is it necessary to engage a qualified intermediary to facilitate a 1031 exchange, and what role does the intermediary play in ensuring the exchange meets IRS requirements for tax deferral?